I Work In Technology, Not "Tech"

The last three decades have seen a remarkable shift in the way we work, think and interface with each other and the culture at large, mostly because of the little bricks of plastic and glass in our pockets that hold the computing power that once ran nations and global corporations. And yet those are just the portals to a wider world of hardware and software that defines the world in which we now live. At the same time, the idea of technology itself has become suspect- and for good reason.

Every large-scale innovation of the last half century has led to a sharp rise in hazards for everyday people. And it's not just obvious stuff like ransomware and crypto, either. Big Data was supposed to bring efficiency and relevance to online experiences, but companies just used it to harvest and sell our personal data. Suckers like me thought user-generated content would democratize media, but it just led to YouTubers shilling Minecraft servers that teach children how to gamble. We thought AI would cure cancer, but so far it's mainly being used to scam consumers with generated images of non-existent products and perpetrate fraud on a scale most of us didn't realize was possible. Not great. Not humanity's best work.

By and large, we don't use technology to solve problems anymore. We use technology to create and monetize them. In this case, the word "we" refers to the industry, but we could widen that to include regulators who turn a blind eye and speculative investors who care less about the business plan than they do the short-term upside of the IPO. And there's another word with which I have a bit of a nit to pick: "technology" is an evolving set of tools that aim to help people solve real problems, "tech" is an industry full of high-functioning sociopaths who want to drain you of all your cash like a butchered pig. So, no. I don't work in "tech." I work in technology. I work with people who identify and solve problems.

Technology used to stand in for a bright crystalline future with flying cars, a tool for helping people live more fulfilling lives, getting better every year. Where did that go off course? I don't mean the flying cars; those were probably always a terrible idea. When did we go from creating life-saving antibiotics to saddling consumers with endless subscriptions to software they do not want or need? When did technology become tech?

One question all companies should ask is this: are we in technology or tech? Think of the classic Mitchell and Webb sketch with the SS officers on the eastern front during WWII: "Are we the baddies?" Is the company focused on customers or monetization? Is the product or service addressing an existing problem or was the problem created in order for the product or service to have a market? Can users buy their software that runs locally and has minimal communication with their cloud services or does the company force them to lease it? During planning, does the company anticipate how their products will be used and abused?

Sometimes it's easy, especially with nuisance communication like spam. If it takes more than one click to unsubscribe, congrats, you are a spammer. If you assume anyone who does business with you wants emails from you, guess what? You're a spammer. I get somewhere between 20 and 30 spam calls every day, all of them automated. Someone created that system, probably with good intentions, and where is it now? It's in tech.

The future looks a bit dimmer than it did before tech bros steamrolled technology, and without real regulation there's no limit to the damage they can do to the economy and the job market generally. The same people who bragged about creating a car where opening the glovebox is subscription-locked are not going to hesitate to replace you with automation, even if that automated version of you is substantially worse in every way. If the product suffers and they have successfully built a moat around their industry to keep out competition, why would they care if your consumer experience is terrible? For a long time, we reassured ourselves that they would never go ahead with this because it would shrink their own customer base as other companies reduce headcount in favor of dodgy automation, but it's become clear that we cannot assume that they know this or care. These people are in tech. Any expectation of rational thought beyond "$++ = better" is off the table.

This is why I don't admit to working in "tech" when someone asks. I work in technology.

Solve problems. Don't become them.